Week 2: July 7-13

[quote=“amydicampbell, post:1, topic:1629”]
Promoting Emergent Literacy Skills (JVIB, 2018, p. 542-550)

  1. How might the cultural background or socioeconomic status of families impact their ability to implement the suggested strategies for promoting emergent literacy in toddlers with visual impairments?

I knew in the school setting that cultural and socioeconomic status really impacts families and their students. It has been a different approach in my new role. I get to go into families home. I make suggestions and if the families are able to follow through, that is great, but if they don’t, not much else we can do.). I do feel that I had more control over the situation in the school setting because every student is the same in that setting. When you visit homes, I get an insight of what the family does, how they live, what kind of activities they do with their children. I normally bring some items into the house to work on vision activities, but usually we work with toys that the family has available. Some houses that we go into are taken care of and some houses aren’t. Some homes have lots of resources in toys and such, others don’t. Providing the families with resource to get certain toys or receive support is very important.
One family that I currently service, doesn’t see that vision is very important. I have found it difficult because I have explained it over again (in several different ways). The primary provider and I took a different approach this last time and encouraged the sister to play with her brother and showed her how to play using his vision. We are hoping this will provide some motivation that will carry out throughout his early intervention services.

1 Like

At the end of each week, I review with the student their strengths and weaknesses so that they can see where they need to improve. I have never heard of the “Rose, bud, and thorn” concept, but feel it could be a way to keep consistent on what is reviewed each week. Thank you for providing information about this technique.

1 Like

Since I was a reading specialist before becoming a TVI, I was familiar with Dyslexia. I was already familiar with it being a brain based disorder (neurobiological). However, since coming into the world of VI, I have had many teachers refer students to me for services as something being wrong with their student’s “vision” when it really was more brain based and had characteristics of dyslexia. This video opened by stating that they were looking at finding dyslexia in students already diagnosed with VI. This detail is critical! I often have to show these teachers its not a matter of the student not being able to “see” its about a struggling process in the brain. Many case managers believe that if we provide services for other brain based neurological disorders such as CVI we should be able to help with reading difficulties such as dyslexia. and it doesn’t help that there are a lack of resources to evaluate it! All this adds to the confusion surrounding it! I appreciate this video for clarity sake!
As for the simulation activity, I will start by saying I could clearly “see” every letter on the page, but yet the “words” listed just didn’t make sense to me. It was time consuming to use the key to decipher them and it took a lot of mental effort that I wasn’t used to expelling while I read. I can for sure say that “reading” like this would take away my love for reading. It would no longer be a past time I enjoy but rather work to endure. This gives me greater empathy for what students with dyslexia face but it also solidified for me that it is brain based disorder and not a visual one like so many try to classify it.

2 Likes

I agree with you that while these strategies would be effective in the classroom, it is not feasible for teachers to know every student’s native language and the differences in the English phonemes. In addition, how would you be able to know synonyms in the native language while in the moment teaching. It would take time to use translation software to get them. I have often found that kids in ESOL don’t always know when they misunderstand something. So they will not always ask questions about passages or phrases, idioms, etc. and will move on with partial knowledge. This takes time to figure out… While all of these strategies are ideal, they are best in a small group or one to one setting and whole class instruction without knowledge of their native language would prove to make these strategies more oddficult to implement.

Though I have never worked in this role professionally in the home, I am quite sure that you see a whole different perspective. I agree that the classroom seems to let you have more control in the sense that at least you can guarantee while the student is at school, they are getting access to the support and materials they need. Although I do not provide early intervention services in the home, I do see families like you describe where they don’t see vision as important. Because attendance in NC is not compulsory until a child turns 7, we often have families who will choose to not get early intervention services, stop services, or just not enroll their students until they are required to a kindergarten or age 7. This usually just exacerbates the difficulties the student will have. I feel like this sometimes isn’t evident until the student gets to middle school age and they really start to struggle because they’ve really been playing catch up the whole time, but when the get to middle school it’s game-on, and the student is not ready.

I am glad to read that even as a person who has been trained as a reading specialist, you also have the difficulty of teachers referring students because a “vision” issue when it is really brain based. At least a couple of times I have had referrals for students for VI. In looking over the concerns and medical documentation that the team had before the referral, it did not seem to me that there was a vision issue. And in fact, the eye doctor’s report said so much–the student had good acuity, no indication of CVI, and no indication of eye movement disorder. However, the parent(s) were insistent that we complete the entire battery of evaluations related to vision. After the assessment, I felt bad because I could not come up with any reason the student’s “vision” was impacting education, and I explained as much to the parent. However, I did not doubt, based on my own observation, that the student really had trouble reading. So at the end of the assessment, no one felt good because everyone knew the student was really struggling with reading, but I couldn’t tell them why or make any recommendations other than generalized good practice recommendations.

4. Reflect on the seven specific suggestions provided for teachers of reading classes with ELLs. How practical and feasible are these suggestions in real classroom contexts?

In addition to my certification in teaching students with visual impairments, I have an endorsement in teaching English learners. As with many of the accommodations for students with IEPs or 504s, I find many of the seven specific suggestions to be effective strategies for ALL kids, not just ELLs. One of the most beneficial takeaways from my understanding of working with EL students is knowing the difference between BICS and CALP. BICS (Basic Interpersonal Communicative Skills) is conversational proficiency, which develops much quicker and is not as cognitively demanding. Whereas CALP (Cognitive Academic Language Proficiency) is required for formal academic learning and can take years to develop.

I also want to mention that several of these key strategies can be applied to students who are D/deaf or hard of hearing, as their native language may not be English, and language deprivation could be a factor. Teachers who work with students who are deafblind may find these seven specific suggestions helpful.

As an itinerant, I think time constraints pose the biggest hurdle to implementing these suggestions in real classroom contexts. My husband is a 7th grade Life Science teacher. Since I have limited experience as a classroom teacher, I often ask his opinions on whether my recommendations can be integrated into existing practices with proper planning and support. He shares the realities of teaching middle school students, and his feedback shapes how I approach other classroom teachers.

1 Like

Hello,
I have had similar experiences with the general education teachers not having high expectations for my VI students. Many times the VI students are paired with the higher level students and then the VI student will just sit there and are not responsible for any work. As more and more things are done for them they do become more and more helpless expecting everything to be done for them. My VI students are getting a good grade based on the work of the group which they did not contribute to. Many of my middle and high school students love this. (which is normal for any teenager) Unfortunately this is sending the message that they do not need to try and that there are no expectations for them. In the article it states, “High-expectation teachers avoid ability-grouping students within the classroom during learning tasks.” In this instance the teacher is using a “high expectation” method but they expectations are not the same for each student. This is a struggle for me since I am an itinerant teacher and am not there all the time to make sure this is not happening. This is a big frustration for me.

3 Likes

Yes! I agree with you whole heartedly. We have to be aware of the challenges our families may face so that we can do our job in a respectful and compassionate way. I think that your comments support the information we learned about this week regarding having high expectations, which applies not just to our students, but to the families as well. :slightly_smiling_face:

Thank you for describing your experience in elementary school. It sounds as though your second-grade teacher went above and beyond to make sure you had the accommodations you needed to be successful in the classroom and then motivated you to do your best. Too many times I find that the classroom teacher feels as though our students with a visual impairment are a burden and will hold their other students back because they feel uncomfortable changing their teaching style. As a teacher of the blind and visually impaired, I find that this is a daily frustration to constantly be the advocate for students with a visual impairment. My motivator was my teacher of the blind and visually impaired. She did not allow me to use my blindness as a crutch and I saw firsthand how she interacted with classroom teachers to ensure that I had the necessary accommodations. I now find that I do the same thing by not allowing my students to use their blindness as a way to get out of completing an assignment, but instead by working with the teacher and finding out how best to complete an assignment with the skills they have.

1 Like

I have had similar experiences and I have even had the developmental optometrist (same ones who diagnose CI) give these students reading glasses (with minimal prescription) to “help them” with their reading struggles even though the eye report did not show a need. So many blurred lines with who provides the services and what they fall under really make the job more difficult these days.

1 Like

2 Reflecting on your own experiences as a student, how did teacher expectations influence your academic performance and motivation? How might you apply these insights to your own teaching practice?

I realize that my academic journey is most likely different from others in this cohort. I am totally blind. I was diagnosed with ROP shortly after birth. Growing up, I was legally blind, with having no vision in my right eye, and very little vision in my left eye. Throughout my elementary years of school I was not receiving vision services due to not having a TVI where I was living. I used a cC-TV throughout my early elementary school years and I worked with an intervention specialist, my general education teacher,and a classroom aide that was assigned to me. My parents wanted to give me every opportunity possible, even though vision services were scarce where we were living. I can remember always being read to at a young age. My parents would read me books. They would let me turn the pages even though I couldn’t fully see the pictures. My mom would describe the pictures to me. They would let me put the books up close to my face to look at the pictures when I was very young, before I even got my CC-TV. I can remember going on bike rides with my dad, sitting in the toddler seat of his bike. We would stop frequently so he could show me things in my environment; trees, leaves, flowers, whatever he thought I needed to know about. When. Was with other family members they would read me books. I especially remember my grandmother reading to me the Little House on the Prairie books. When I would play house with my dolls, I would read to them, recounting the stories that had been told or read to me, I would then retell them to my dolls. I believe all of these experiences helped me foster a love for reading before I entered kindergarten.

Once I was in kindergarten, I got my first CC-TV. It was then that learning took off for me. Teachers were concerned about having me in their classes since I had a severe visual impairment, but once they saw that I was a determined little girl who wanted to learn, their nerves melted away. I was a people pleaser, I still am as an adult, but as a child, I wanted to show the adults in my life that I could succeed despite my blindness. I wanted to do everything that my sighted peers were doing. My parents had expectations for me. They wanted me to go to college,and they wanted me to have the tools to be successful to allow me higher education. In my early elementary years, I used my CC-TV for everything. I learned to read and write in print that way. I had my aide to assist when I needed it, but I wanted to read. I loved a book that had a dramatic story. I was drawn to the books of series, Sweet Valley Kids and Baby-Sitter’s Club books were my favorites. Once I learned the foundations of reading from my general education teachers in kindergarten, first,and second grades, along with working with an intervention specialist for more intensive reading practice, I enjoyed reading even more.

When I entered the fifth grade, my family moved to an area that allowed me to have a TVI. During this time, my learning took off in ways that amazed me, even when I think about them to this day. My TVI taught me braille. She wanted me to know how to read and write Braille in case I were to lose my vision. This excited me. I wanted to learn and do well. I don’t rmember the braille code being hard to learn. I gravitated to it. As a motivator, my TVI would get me books that I found interesting, mainly Baby-Sitter’s Club books by my fifth grade year. She would give me print and braille books to take home to read with my parents to practice my braille skills. I labeled things around the house to help with my braille reading. My mom would dictate her grocery list to me,and I would braille it. I’d then go. Shopping with her,and read my brailled list back to her. I believe all of these things helped to make me a strong braille reader.

Once in middle school, high school,and even college, I was a dual media learner, using my CC-TV and Braille. I would use audio when necessary, but my first choice was to always read it, whether that be in print with my CC-TV or in Braille. Once done with college, and in my first year of teaching, I lost the little sight that I had. I am now totally blind,and I rely on Braille and audio to access print information. As a totally blind, I still prefer Braille to read verses audio. Although, I know that Braille isn’t always possible, but I think that will always be my first preference. I love the words beneath my fingertips. I enjoy being able to sit with the words that I’m reading,and try to create a mental picture in my mind. I feel that we don’t necessarily get that creativeness when listening to audio.

As a TVI, I try to give my students motivation that will hopefully help them enjoy reading. Whether it’s a certain genre of book to read, or it’s something that has nothing to do with the act of reading, I try to find what motivates them to want to read. Music is a real motivator for some of my students. I had a student who loved Taylor Swift. We would have a Braille lesson, and after the lesson she would listen to a Taylor song if she had completed the lesson well. To help with brailling and spelling, I would have her listen to a Taylor Swift song,and braille words that she liked from the song. Music was her motivator. It seemed to fuel her wanting to learn,and I tried to incorporate it into learning every chance I could. I believe that finding that motivator for students,and working it into instruction is key to help foster reading.

Sharon, I completely agree with what you are saying. As a TVI, who is blind, I find myself so many times advocating for my students, to allow them the same education opportunities as their sighted peers. I tell teachers that the visual impairment can’t hold the child back. We can’t let it hold them back,and we must find another way to allow the child to complete the same work as their sighted peers. A lot of time I find that means that we need to really be keyed into our students strengths. Also helping our students to advocate for themselves to tell the genreral education teachers what their strengths are and how they can use those strengths to complete an assignment. Reading is across every content area of learning,and sometimes what is asked of our students might need to be altered a bit to meet them where they’re at. I really think that is key in helping students understand their strength and how they can use them to complete assignments. Working with the general education teacher to help them understand that the child with a visual impairment sees the world differently s the first step in helping our students.

I have families with these issues - their ability to obtain materials to utilize these strategies can be limited. Making braille and tactile adaptations to a book is time consuming and buying books can be costly. Even free resources involve forms and looking on a website that involves a computer or device etc. They may speak different languages - this may make websites and apps harder to navigate and access. Having braille materials that are also understandable to the non-English speaking caregivers can be a real challenge. If the parents are still learning about the unique needs of their emergent reader they may feel overwhelmed or unsure what to do. Taking care of a small child is a big task - having a child who has specialized needs, medical issues and so forth can make that task even bigger. There is a lot on the list of parental duties and we as professionals need to find the balance to help parents without making them feel like there isn’t enough time to do all the things. I have provided materials for my parents that we are also using in the classroom - I have shared songs and rhyming activities that they can incorporate into everyday living. Helping parents to understand that literacy activities can be as simple as building language during a meal time gives them tools to use that will produce results without adding on to an already busy day. I emphasize to all my families as well as classroom teachers to describe events/actions/tactile information during meaningful moments - just as the article states - so the child has a practical hands on context related experience to go along with the description. I think too, emphasizing to parents that any story activity - even one where the child is just listening - can be made active given the way you involve the child - giving those completion prompts, asking those wh questions, expanding on the language skills they have - this builds those foundational literacy skills to get them more ready for whatever medium they will use for reading.

Thank you for sharing your experiences as a student who has a visual impairment. Being a TVI myself, I feel that having high expectations for our students can only help them. Granted, we may have to change our expectations to meet our students where they are at, but having expectation is better then not having any at all. I don’t think the visual impairment should be used as a crutch,and I often work with my students to help them key in on their strengths as learners. Even though ther eyes may not allow them to see n all the ways as their sighted peers do, they still have strengths. I think it’s important for them to own those strengths,and help them build their strengths into the expectations that teachers have. Expectations can only help us grow,and I think it’s important for students to learn how to work with expectations.

When I work with a general education teacher, I always tell them to make their expectations clear and ask my student what their interpretation is of what is being expected of them. If we want students to strive for the expectations then we need to make sure that the student understands what is being expected of them.Having that dialogue with students is so important,and can really set the stage for success.

I knew that Dyslexia was more neurological but this video really did illustrate for me more completely how. I did the activity and found the same as you - reading is so automatic for many people - until you see all the complexity of trying to put those pieces together and having something making that process more arduous. I have often wondered this about braille contractions - how much do they hinder the reading process? Excellent question!

I love that you found reading your OWN way! I think with technology we can do so much with multi-media learners! I agree completely that helping students find motivation to read is key and meeting them where they are is so important. I always find out what my students are interested in or at least try to connect readings we are using in instruction to their interests. I also think it is so important to reward effort - our braille readers are learning a lot all at once incorporating so many layers. I love going over the braille goals we have with students and talking about how now we know whichever contractions that at the beginning of the year we didn’t or at the start of whatever marking period we said we would learn words to decode and now we have. Keeping students informed of how far they have come is a key to their success!

Reflecting on your own experiences as a student, how did teacher expectations influence your academic performance and motivation? How might you apply these insights to your own teaching practice?

As a student I understood teachers expectations and worked hard to meet the expectations of the teachers. By nature I am a people pleaser, so meeting expectations of my teachers was important to me. I was always very young for my grade, an October birthday so often I was a full year younger than my peers. Developmentally my brain was not ready for many of the concepts that came easily to my peers. When I was unable to meet these expectations I felt very upset and the feelings of not doing well or feeling frustrated that I let a teacher down lingered with me for a while and often left me feeling inadequate. At some point in high school, freshman/sophmore year I really gave up all together. I was able to pull it together and with the help of some really good teachers that helped me believe that I did have what it took to be successful I graduated and went on to college. These experiences really helped me as a teacher understand that having expectations for students is a balancing act of providing challenges, believing in the students, and inspiring them to not feel defeated if they struggle. It also helped me create a classroom environment where my students felt validated by me when they were successful, but also when they did not understand concepts. My experiences bought compassion and understanding to my practice that really made me a teacher that year after year students would seek out to say Hi, come back to my classroom to take a break from stresses in their classrooms, and visit my classroom to show me their work, read me a book they newly learned to read, or simply pop in for a hug.

I like how you encourage teachers you work with to ask the students what their interpretation of the expectations are, this is so powerful but also ensures understanding is there. I find with many students they may not know what a general statement like “being a good student means” so they don’t know what to do in class. But if I break it down and say to be a good student you should: take notes, correct incorrect answers etc. the student understands what needs to be done to be successful and will do it. They weren’t not doing these things to be lazy or because they didn’t care, it just hadn’t occurred to them that that’s what they were expected to do.

I have had a similar experience with a student. It can be very hard to identify where the reading difficulty is stemming from. The student I evaluated did show some difficulties with convergence, but I really felt that the students processing was delayed.